Controlling 4140 Steel Microstructure and Properties Through Heat Treatment


4140 alloy steel derives its versatile properties like high strength, toughness, and wear resistance through heat treatment. Proper heating and cooling transforms the metal’s microstructure to achieve desired characteristics. Heat treatment is a metallurgical science requiring in-depth understanding of time, temperature, and quenching effects on 4140 steel’s microstructural evolution.

This guide examines how various heat treating processes control the phase transformations, grain size, defect structure, and precipitates within the microstructure of 4140 steel to develop tailored properties. We will look at the science behind annealing, normalizing, hardening, tempering, and stress relieving treatments.

Overview of 4140 Steel

4140 steel contains nominally 0.40% carbon content along with 1% chromium and 0.20% molybdenum. The low alloy composition enables hardening through heat treatment to high strength levels. Other elements like manganese and silicon optimize hardenability and secondary properties.

In the as-rolled condition, 4140 steel has a ferritic-pearlitic microstructure with fine lamellar pearlite and some banded segregation from hot working. The microstructure at this stage provides good machinability but low hardness.

Heat treatment transforms the microstructure by altering phase proportions, reducing defects, and introducing hardness-improving precipitates. This creates the ultimate balance of strength, toughness, and wear resistance needed for various applications.

Now let’s look at how specific heat treatments actually change the 4140 steel microstructure at the grain level.

Microstructural Changes During Annealing

Full annealing involves heating 4140 steel to ~1550°F into the austenite region, holding for sufficient time, then slowly cooling. This produces a coarse, equiaxed ferrite-pearlite microstructure optimal for machinability. Here’s what happens:

  • Austenitizing eliminates worked structure and transforms to FCC austenite
  • Slow cooling enables precipitates like carbides and nitrides to dissolve into austenite
  • Austenite transforms slowly to coarse ferrite and lamellar pearlite
  • Improves ductility and toughness but lowers strength and hardness

Process annealing uses slightly lower temperatures (~1400°F) and faster air cooling to avoid excessive softness. The microstructure still coarsens somewhat for improved machinability with some reduction in mechanical properties.

Normalizing Refines the Grain Structure

Normalizing involves heating 4140 steel to 1650-1700°F in the austenite region followed by air cooling. This refines the ferrite grain size and reduces segregation, producing a uniform fine-grained pearlitic-ferritic microstructure ideal for hardening.

  • Heating dissociates pearlite into austenite and dissolves micro-segregation
  • Air cooling transforms austenite into fine islands of ferrite and lamellar pearlite
  • Fine grain size increases hardness and strength
  • Normalizing relieves residual stresses from prior working

The normalized condition restores ductility and toughness prior to hardening 4140 steel components.

Hardening and High Temperature Tempering

Hardening 4140 steel involves heating into the austenite phase field around 1550-1650°F and then rapidly quenching in oil or water. This produces very hard martensite phase through diffusionless transformation. The associated microstructural changes are:

  • Complete austenitization at high temperature
  • Supersaturation of carbon in austenite due to rapid quenching
  • Formation of highly strained, tetragonal crystalline martensite
  • Martensite provides very high hardness and strength

Tempering after hardening follows to reduce brittleness and restore needed ductility and toughness. Tempering involves holding at temperatures 250-750°F which enables the following:

  • Tetragonal martensite decomposes to form tempered martensite
  • Some degree of cementite precipitation occurs
  • Retained austenite transforms to lamellar ferrite-cementite
  • Dislocation density decreases due to recovery

Proper quenching and tempering thus maximizes hardness through martensite while controlling brittleness through tempered martensite formation.

Low Temperature Tempering

Tempering 4140 steel at lower temperatures below 250°F introduces fine epsilon carbide precipitates from carbon supersaturated martensite, producing secondary hardening. Key changes are:

  • Fine coherent epsilon carbide precipitates formed
  • High dislocation density maintained in martensite
  • Retained austenite not significantly decomposed
  • Achieves optimal mix of hardness and toughness

Low temperature tempering produces the best combination of strength and toughness for high duty components from 4140 steel.

Stress Relieving 4140 Steel

Stress relieving involves heating 4140 steel components to a temperature of 1200-1250°F and then slowly cooling. The key effects are:

  • Recovery and partial recrystallization softens the microstructure
  • Residual stresses from prior cold or hot working are relieved
  • Distortion and risk of cracking during subsequent machining is minimized
  • Ductility and toughness improve while hardness reduces slightly

Stress relieving is vital for ensuring dimensional stability when machining hot rolled or normalized 4140 steel products prior to finish grinding.

Controlling Hardness, Strength, and Toughness

By controlling heating temperatures, holding times, and quenching or cooling parameters, heat treaters can tailor the microstructure, hardness, and mechanical properties of 4140 steel to achieve the optimal combination of strength, toughness, and wear properties necessary for the intended application and service environment.

Effect of Alloying Elements on 4140 Steel Properties

The alloying elements in 4140 steel – chromium, molybdenum, manganese, silicon, nickel, etc. – have specific effects on its microstructure and properties. Understanding these effects guides alloy optimization.


  • Primary alloying element at 0.8-1.1% level
  • Increases hardenability and tensile strength
  • Enables deeper hardness penetration on quenching
  • Provides mild corrosion resistance


  • Added at 0.15-0.25% level
  • Significantly increases high temperature strength
  • Enhances hardenability for thicker sections
  • Improves wear resistance and toughness


  • Added in 0.7-0.9% range
  • Acts as mild deoxidizer during steelmaking
  • Increases hardenability and tensile strength
  • Enables quench cracking resistance


  • Typically restricted to 0.15-0.35% max
  • Improves strength without reducing ductility
  • Helps resist softening at high service temperatures
  • Deoxidizes and increases grain coarsening resistance


  • Optional addition up to 0.25%
  • Further increases toughness and ductility
  • Adds incremental strength and hardenability
  • Helps refine ferrite grain size

These elements in optimal quantities enable 4140 steel to offer a versatile balance of fabricability, weldability, strength, toughness, and wear properties critical for reliability across industrial applications.

Effect of Tempering Temperature on Hardness

Tempering is critical after quenching 4140 steel to restore needed ductility and toughness. The temperature controls the changes in hardness based on microstructural evolution:


  • Maximum hardness preserved through martensite retention
  • Fine epsilon carbides precipitate within martensite
  • Minimal reduction of hardness – Only 2-3 HRC


  • Hardness gradually declines as tempering progresses
  • Martensite decomposes to transition carbides
  • Decline of 6-9 HRC depending on section size


  • Significant drop in hardness begins
  • Tempered martensite formation accelerates
  • Carbides coagulate into spherical particles
  • Hardness reduced by 10-14 HRC points


  • Tempering is nearly complete
  • Majority of martensite is tempered
  • Significant reconstitution of ferrite-carbide mix
  • Hardness falls another 10-12 HRC

Higher hardness causes brittleness. Lower hardness reduces strength. The optimum tempering temperature balances hardness against toughness based on application loads and service conditions the 4140 steel part will encounter.

Effect of Cooling Rate on Hardness

For hardening 4140 steel, the rate of cooling after austenitizing controls the transformation behavior resulting in different hardness levels:

Rapid Quenching

  • Fast cooling in oil or water quench
  • Produces fully martensitic microstructure
  • Achieves maximum hardness – HRC 50-55+
  • High risk of quench cracking

Air Cooling

  • Moderate cooling rate in ambient air
  • Mix of martensite and bainite forms
  • Medium hardness around HRC 40-45
  • Lower risk of cracking

Furnace Cooling

  • Slow cooling in furnace at 100-200°F/hr
  • Pearlitic-ferritic microstructure results
  • Low hardness in 20-30 HRC range
  • No cracking issues

Interrupted Cooling

  • Combination of quench, partial air cool and temper
  • Balances transformation phases
  • Tailors hardness level as needed
  • Controls distortion and cracking

For maximum hardness, fast quenching of 4140 steel is needed. But slower cooling or interrupted cooling can be optimized to achieve application-specific hardness profiles without cracking.

Quality Control Testing for Heat Treated 4140 Steel

To validate proper heat treatment of 4140 steel, several quality control tests are performed to verify the microstructure, hardness, and mechanical properties against specifications:

Microstructure Testing

  • Optical metallography to assess grain structure
  • Validates complete austenitization
  • Checks for presence of required phases
  • Detects grain growth, banding, or defects

Hardness Testing

  • Rockwell or Vickers hardness tests
  • Monitors hardness profile on cross section
  • Confirms hardening and tempering done per requirements
  • Identifies any soft spots indicating improper heating

Tensile Testing

  • Measures tensile and yield strength of heat treated parts
  • Determines ductility from elongation and reduction of area
  • Validates mechanical properties as specified

Impact Testing

  • Monitors impact energy and ductility
  • Verifies desired toughness levels are achieved
  • Confirms proper tempering of hardened steel

Macro Etch Testing

  • Large scale etching to reveal material defects
  • Checks for voids, cracks, inclusions, and segregation

Effective quality control testing validates heat treatment, hardness, grain structure, tensile properties, toughness, and material quality per engineering requirements for 4140 steel.

Effect of Section Size on Hardenability

The depth of hardening achieved during quenching 4140 steel depends on the section size of the component. This relates to hardenability – the ability to form martensite during rapid cooling.

Thin Sections

  • Rapid quenching quickly forms martensite
  • Full hardness achieved even in air cool or shallow oil
  • Ex: Gears, pins, fasteners

Medium Sections

  • Oil quenching needed to enable full martensite through thickness
  • Some partial softening may still occur in core
  • Ex: Shafts, cylinders, thicker plates

Thick Sections

  • Intensive water quenching required
  • Oil cooling risks softer core and lower hardness
  • Can utilize interrupted quenching methods
  • Ex: Large rolls, press frames, thick weldments

4140 has good hardenability thanks to its alloying additions. But hardness depth remains limited in very thick sections unless optimal quenchant and temperature are utilized. Cooling rates must be tailored to ensure hardness penetration aligns with design performance requirements.

Causes of Quench Cracking in 4140 Steel

While fast cooling is essential to harden 4140 steel, it can also lead to quench cracking under certain conditions:

Restraint Conditions

  • Constraint of part during quenching
  • Inability to shrink freely induces stress
  • Leads to hot tear cracking on quench

Thick Sections

  • Severe thermal gradients between surface and core
  • Plastic flow gradients amplify tensile stress
  • Cracks initiate at vulnerable interior points

Improper Quenching

  • Very cold water or brine media
  • Aggravates thermal stresses
  • Encourages hydrogen flaking damage

Alloy Segregation

  • Chemical segregation from improper melting
  • Areas of reduced hardenability crack more easily

Prior Cold Work

  • Increases hardness and brittleness
  • Residual stresses add to quench stresses
  • Cracking tendency rises

Pre-Existing Flaws

  • Defects like forging laps act as crack initiation sites
  • Microshrinkage pores or microcracks are vulnerable

Controlling geometry, restraint, quenchant temperature, alloy quality, prior processing, and defects minimizes quench cracking. Proper tempering immediately after quenching also relieves residual stresses.

Smoothest Hardness Profiles Through Interrupted Quenching of 4140 Steel

When hardening large cross-sections of 4140 steel, conventional quenching can result in a harsh transition between the martensitic surface and softer core. The resulting hardness differential causes performance issues.

Interrupted quenching provides a solution by gradually reducing the cooling rate. This enables a more uniform transition from surface to center:

Step 1

  • Rapid quench in cold medium from 1650°F austenitizing temperature

Step 2

  • Transfer to hotter quenchant when surface reaches 400-500°F

Step 3

  • Slow cool through pearlite to ferrite range before reaching room temperature


  • Gradual microstructure transition
  • Reduced thermal gradients
  • Smoother hardness profile
  • Low risk of cracking

With interrupted quenching, 4140 steel parts experience a controlled drop in cooling rates through the various microstructure transformation ranges. This achieves a holistic hardness pattern optimized for performance.

Effect of Tempering Temperature on Toughness

For quenched and hardened 4140 steel, tempering treatment has a key influence on balancing strength against toughness:

Low Temperature (250-375°F)

  • Maximum hardness retention
  • Only slight gain in toughness
  • Risk of brittle fracture remains high

Medium Temperature (400-600°F)

  • Declining hardness as tempering progresses
  • Significant rise in toughness due to tempered martensite
  • Ductility improves notably

High Temperature (650-750°F)

  • Approaching fully tempered condition
  • Major increase in toughness and impact strength
  • Ductility and reduction of area improves further

Excessive Temperature

  • Tempering completes but some over-tempering occurs
  • Excess softening lowers strength below requirements
  • Highest toughness but inadequate hardness

The optimum tempering temperature balances the toughness gains against the hardness loss based on required mechanical properties. Toughness is improved at the slight expense of hardness to achieve the best combination.

Effect of Tempering Time on Hardness

While temperature primarily controls the tempering effect, duration held at temperature also influences hardness reduction and property changes when tempering 4140 steel:

Short Duration

  • Insufficient time for required carbide transformations
  • May not completely temper full thickness of sections
  • Retains higher hardness

Moderate Duration

  • Enables thorough decomposition of martensite
  • Timed to allow optimal phase transformations
  • Achieves full tempering without over-tempering

Prolonged Duration

  • Excessive time permits grain coarsening
  • Complete tempering and partial over-tempering
  • Possible lower hardness than desired

Cyclic Tempering

  • Multiple shorter cycles at tempering temperature
  • Each cycle progresses tempering reactions further
  • More uniform tempering across section thickness

The proper tempering duration, whether in single or multiple cycles, is predetermined for each steel thickness to attain targeted hardness levels without under-tempering or over-tempering.

Preventing Decarburization and Oxidation During Heat Treating

When heat treating 4140 steel, maintaining a protective atmosphere is critical to prevent decarburization and oxidation which damage the properties:

Decarburization Prevention

  • Use sealed furnace with controlled inert gas atmosphere
  • Avoid open air environments when austenitizing above 1400°F
  • Hydrogen or nitrogen atmosphere prevents carbon loss

Oxidation Prevention

  • Ensure positive pressure inert atmosphere
  • No leaks allowing air infiltration
  • Purge/seal quench tanks to exclude air contact
  • Keep furnace oxygen levels below 5 ppm
  • Use methane additions to further minimize oxygen

Protective Coatings

  • Apply anti-scale compounds to shield parts
  • Use aluminum foil wraps of parts if necessary
  • Minimizes air exposure during quenching

Monitoring Atmosphere

  • Continuously monitor furnace gas analysis
  • Ensure proper temperature uniformity
  • Be alert for any atmosphere control issues

Maintaining protective conditions ensures heat treated 4140 steel achieves full hardness and specified mechanical properties without loss of alloy content.

Share your love
Update cookies preferences